PROB
Quirk foundCategory: Statistical · Last tested 2026-09-01
Real compatibility results for the PROB function: executed in Excel for the web, Google Sheets and LibreOffice Calc, with desktop Excel behavior from Microsoft’s official documentation (we do not run desktop Excel — Excel for the web is a different application and is executed separately). Syntax and links to that documentation are below.
Support matrix
| Engine | Documented | Live-tested | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Excel (desktop) | Yes | No — documented only | n/a |
| Excel for the web | — | Yes (recalc, 2026-09-01) | Quirk found |
| Google Sheets | Yes | Yes (Drive import, 2026-08-31) | Quirk found |
| LibreOffice Calc | Yes | Yes (25.8.7.3, 2026-08-31) | Quirk found |
LibreOffice version history
We executed the same test cases under each LibreOffice release to show exactly when PROB’s support changed — not documentation claims, real results.
| LibreOffice version | Verdict | Tested |
|---|---|---|
| 24.2.0.3 | Quirk found | 2026-08-31 |
| 24.8.7.2 | Quirk found | 2026-08-31 |
| 25.2.0.3 | Quirk found | 2026-08-31 |
| 25.8.7.3 | Quirk found | 2026-08-31 |
Why isn't PROB working in LibreOffice?
PROB exists in LibreOffice 25.8.7.3, but it is not a drop-in match for
Excel — our executed tests found real behavioral differences (detailed in the test results on this
page). If a formula that works in Excel or Google Sheets misbehaves in LibreOffice, compare your usage
against the failing cases above before assuming your data is wrong.
Why isn’t PROB working in Google Sheets?
PROB runs in Google Sheets, but our executed cases show it does not match
Excel’s documented behavior on every input (the failing cases are listed on this page). If a
formula that behaves one way in Excel gives you a different answer in Sheets, compare your usage
against those cases before assuming your data is wrong.
Discovered quirks
-
=PROB(A3:A6,D3:D6,2) on
Excel for the web returned
0.1, but the documented/expected
result is #NUM!.
Provenance
Microsoft documents: "If any value in prob_range <= 0 or if any value in prob_range > 1, PROB returns the #NUM! error value." The D column is deliberately built to sum to exactly 1 (1.5 + 0.3 + 0.1 - 0.9 = 1.0) so that the OTHER documented constraint is satisfied and only the per-value range rule can fire -- otherwise a passing result would not say which rule the engine enforced.; MISMATCH vs expected: expected '#NUM!', got 0.1
-
=PROB(A3:A6,C3:C6,2) on
Google Sheets returned
#VALUE!, but the documented/expected
result is #NUM!.
Provenance
Microsoft documents: "If the sum of the values in prob_range is not equal to 1, PROB returns the #NUM! error value." The C column sums to 0.9. OpenFormula 1.3 section 6.18.63 states the same constraint.; MISMATCH vs expected: expected '#NUM!', got '#VALUE!'
-
=PROB(A3:A6,D3:D6,2) on
Google Sheets returned
0.1, but the documented/expected
result is #NUM!.
Provenance
Microsoft documents: "If any value in prob_range <= 0 or if any value in prob_range > 1, PROB returns the #NUM! error value." The D column is deliberately built to sum to exactly 1 (1.5 + 0.3 + 0.1 - 0.9 = 1.0) so that the OTHER documented constraint is satisfied and only the per-value range rule can fire -- otherwise a passing result would not say which rule the engine enforced.; MISMATCH vs expected: expected '#NUM!', got 0.1
-
=PROB(A3:A6,C3:C6,2) on
LibreOffice Calc returned
#VALUE!, but the documented/expected
result is #NUM!.
Provenance
Microsoft documents: "If the sum of the values in prob_range is not equal to 1, PROB returns the #NUM! error value." The C column sums to 0.9. OpenFormula 1.3 section 6.18.63 states the same constraint.; MISMATCH vs expected: expected '#NUM!', got '#VALUE!'
-
=PROB(A3:A6,D3:D6,2) on
LibreOffice Calc returned
#VALUE!, but the documented/expected
result is #NUM!.
Provenance
Microsoft documents: "If any value in prob_range <= 0 or if any value in prob_range > 1, PROB returns the #NUM! error value." The D column is deliberately built to sum to exactly 1 (1.5 + 0.3 + 0.1 - 0.9 = 1.0) so that the OTHER documented constraint is satisfied and only the per-value range rule can fire -- otherwise a passing result would not say which rule the engine enforced.; MISMATCH vs expected: expected '#NUM!', got '#VALUE!'
Executed test cases
Excel for the web (executed 2026-09-01 via OneDrive recalculation)
These values come from Excel for the web, not from desktop Excel. They are two different implementations of the calculation engine, and this run measured only the web one: the corpus was uploaded to OneDrive as .xlsx, recalculated by Excel for the web on open, and downloaded again for readback. Excel for the web is a rolling service with no pinnable version, so the run is identified by its date. Where a value here disagrees with the Expected column — which is Microsoft’s documentation of the desktop product — we cannot tell you whether the web engine diverges from the desktop one or the documentation is wrong about both, because we do not run desktop Excel.
| Formula | Description | Result | Expected | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| =ROUND(PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,2),12) | Microsoft's documented example with only a lower limit | 0.1 | 0.1ProvenanceMicrosoft publishes =PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,2) = 0.1 for the values 0, 1, 2, 3 with probabilities 0.2, 0.3, 0.1, 0.4, and documents the rule it exercises: "If upper_limit is omitted, PROB returns the probability of being equal to lower_limit." DERIVATION: with no upper limit the answer is simply the probability attached to the value 2, which is 0.1 -- a lookup, not a calculation. Microsoft's page was re-read live on 2026-08-31 at https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/excel/functions/prob-function (the /en-us/office/<name>-function-<guid> path was returning Microsoft's 'Sorry, the page you're looking for can't be found' body throughout this batch, and the working path serves an 87 KB stub about half the time, so pages were fetched with retries until the payload exceeded 150 KB). |
Matched |
| =ROUND(PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,1,3),12) | Microsoft's documented example with both limits | 0.8 | 0.8ProvenanceMicrosoft publishes =PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,1,3) = 0.8. DERIVATION: the values 1, 2 and 3 all lie in the closed interval [1,3], so the answer is 0.3 + 0.1 + 0.4 = 0.8 exactly. Note that both endpoints are INCLUDED -- OpenFormula 1.3 section 6.18.63 writes the same rule as an indicator over Start <= d_i <= End -- so an engine using a half-open interval would return 0.4 here. |
Matched |
| =ROUND(PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,0,3),12) | Limits spanning the whole sample | 1 | 1ProvenanceEvery value lies in [0,3], so the answer is the sum of all four probabilities, which the page requires to be 1. Structural: it pins both endpoints at once and needs no derived constant. |
Matched |
| =PROB(A3:A6,C3:C6,2) | A probability column that sums to 0.9, which the page excludes | #NUM! | #NUM!ProvenanceMicrosoft documents: "If the sum of the values in prob_range is not equal to 1, PROB returns the #NUM! error value." The C column sums to 0.9. OpenFormula 1.3 section 6.18.63 states the same constraint. |
Matched |
| =PROB(A3:A6,D3:D6,2) | A probability greater than 1 among otherwise valid entries | 0.1 | #NUM!ProvenanceMicrosoft documents: "If any value in prob_range <= 0 or if any value in prob_range > 1, PROB returns the #NUM! error value." The D column is deliberately built to sum to exactly 1 (1.5 + 0.3 + 0.1 - 0.9 = 1.0) so that the OTHER documented constraint is satisfied and only the per-value range rule can fire -- otherwise a passing result would not say which rule the engine enforced. |
Mismatch |
| =PROB(A3:A6,B3:B5,2) | x_range and prob_range of different lengths | #N/A | #N/AProvenanceMicrosoft documents: "If x_range and prob_range contain a different number of data points, PROB returns the #N/A error value." Note the code: #N/A for a shape mismatch, #NUM! for a bad probability -- two different errors on the same page, so they are asserted separately. |
Matched |
Google Sheets (executed 2026-08-31 via Drive import)
Google Sheets is a rolling service with no pinnable version, so this run is identified by its date. The corpus was imported to Drive as .xlsx, recalculated by Sheets, and exported back for readback.
| Formula | Description | Result | Expected | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| =ROUND(PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,2),12) | Microsoft's documented example with only a lower limit | 0.1 | 0.1ProvenanceMicrosoft publishes =PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,2) = 0.1 for the values 0, 1, 2, 3 with probabilities 0.2, 0.3, 0.1, 0.4, and documents the rule it exercises: "If upper_limit is omitted, PROB returns the probability of being equal to lower_limit." DERIVATION: with no upper limit the answer is simply the probability attached to the value 2, which is 0.1 -- a lookup, not a calculation. Microsoft's page was re-read live on 2026-08-31 at https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/excel/functions/prob-function (the /en-us/office/<name>-function-<guid> path was returning Microsoft's 'Sorry, the page you're looking for can't be found' body throughout this batch, and the working path serves an 87 KB stub about half the time, so pages were fetched with retries until the payload exceeded 150 KB). |
Matched |
| =ROUND(PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,1,3),12) | Microsoft's documented example with both limits | 0.8 | 0.8ProvenanceMicrosoft publishes =PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,1,3) = 0.8. DERIVATION: the values 1, 2 and 3 all lie in the closed interval [1,3], so the answer is 0.3 + 0.1 + 0.4 = 0.8 exactly. Note that both endpoints are INCLUDED -- OpenFormula 1.3 section 6.18.63 writes the same rule as an indicator over Start <= d_i <= End -- so an engine using a half-open interval would return 0.4 here. |
Matched |
| =ROUND(PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,0,3),12) | Limits spanning the whole sample | 1 | 1ProvenanceEvery value lies in [0,3], so the answer is the sum of all four probabilities, which the page requires to be 1. Structural: it pins both endpoints at once and needs no derived constant. |
Matched |
| =PROB(A3:A6,C3:C6,2) | A probability column that sums to 0.9, which the page excludes | #VALUE! | #NUM!ProvenanceMicrosoft documents: "If the sum of the values in prob_range is not equal to 1, PROB returns the #NUM! error value." The C column sums to 0.9. OpenFormula 1.3 section 6.18.63 states the same constraint. |
Mismatch |
| =PROB(A3:A6,D3:D6,2) | A probability greater than 1 among otherwise valid entries | 0.1 | #NUM!ProvenanceMicrosoft documents: "If any value in prob_range <= 0 or if any value in prob_range > 1, PROB returns the #NUM! error value." The D column is deliberately built to sum to exactly 1 (1.5 + 0.3 + 0.1 - 0.9 = 1.0) so that the OTHER documented constraint is satisfied and only the per-value range rule can fire -- otherwise a passing result would not say which rule the engine enforced. |
Mismatch |
| =PROB(A3:A6,B3:B5,2) | x_range and prob_range of different lengths | #N/A | #N/AProvenanceMicrosoft documents: "If x_range and prob_range contain a different number of data points, PROB returns the #N/A error value." Note the code: #N/A for a shape mismatch, #NUM! for a bad probability -- two different errors on the same page, so they are asserted separately. |
Matched |
LibreOffice Calc 25.8.7.3 (tested 2026-08-31)
| Formula | Description | Result | Expected | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| =ROUND(PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,2),12) | Microsoft's documented example with only a lower limit | 0.1 | 0.1ProvenanceMicrosoft publishes =PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,2) = 0.1 for the values 0, 1, 2, 3 with probabilities 0.2, 0.3, 0.1, 0.4, and documents the rule it exercises: "If upper_limit is omitted, PROB returns the probability of being equal to lower_limit." DERIVATION: with no upper limit the answer is simply the probability attached to the value 2, which is 0.1 -- a lookup, not a calculation. Microsoft's page was re-read live on 2026-08-31 at https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/excel/functions/prob-function (the /en-us/office/<name>-function-<guid> path was returning Microsoft's 'Sorry, the page you're looking for can't be found' body throughout this batch, and the working path serves an 87 KB stub about half the time, so pages were fetched with retries until the payload exceeded 150 KB). |
Matched |
| =ROUND(PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,1,3),12) | Microsoft's documented example with both limits | 0.8 | 0.8ProvenanceMicrosoft publishes =PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,1,3) = 0.8. DERIVATION: the values 1, 2 and 3 all lie in the closed interval [1,3], so the answer is 0.3 + 0.1 + 0.4 = 0.8 exactly. Note that both endpoints are INCLUDED -- OpenFormula 1.3 section 6.18.63 writes the same rule as an indicator over Start <= d_i <= End -- so an engine using a half-open interval would return 0.4 here. |
Matched |
| =ROUND(PROB(A3:A6,B3:B6,0,3),12) | Limits spanning the whole sample | 1 | 1ProvenanceEvery value lies in [0,3], so the answer is the sum of all four probabilities, which the page requires to be 1. Structural: it pins both endpoints at once and needs no derived constant. |
Matched |
| =PROB(A3:A6,C3:C6,2) | A probability column that sums to 0.9, which the page excludes | #VALUE! | #NUM!ProvenanceMicrosoft documents: "If the sum of the values in prob_range is not equal to 1, PROB returns the #NUM! error value." The C column sums to 0.9. OpenFormula 1.3 section 6.18.63 states the same constraint. |
Mismatch |
| =PROB(A3:A6,D3:D6,2) | A probability greater than 1 among otherwise valid entries | #VALUE! | #NUM!ProvenanceMicrosoft documents: "If any value in prob_range <= 0 or if any value in prob_range > 1, PROB returns the #NUM! error value." The D column is deliberately built to sum to exactly 1 (1.5 + 0.3 + 0.1 - 0.9 = 1.0) so that the OTHER documented constraint is satisfied and only the per-value range rule can fire -- otherwise a passing result would not say which rule the engine enforced. |
Mismatch |
| =PROB(A3:A6,B3:B5,2) | x_range and prob_range of different lengths | #N/A | #N/AProvenanceMicrosoft documents: "If x_range and prob_range contain a different number of data points, PROB returns the #N/A error value." Note the code: #N/A for a shape mismatch, #NUM! for a bad probability -- two different errors on the same page, so they are asserted separately. |
Matched |
Docs & syntax
- Excel (desktop): official documentation
- Google Sheets: official documentation
- LibreOffice Calc: official documentation
Where PROB behaves differently
- Every error code LibreOffice reports as #VALUE!
Across our 2,334-case executed corpus, 272 cases in 135 functions return #VALUE! in LibreOffice Calc 25.8.7.3 where Microsoft documents #NUM! (244), #N/A (15), #DIV/0! (10) or #REF! (3). Google Sheets returns the documented code on 239 of the 249 it has a function for. Identical in all four LibreOffice builds tested.